STO Awakening.jpg

Talk:Tactical Officer (FED)

From Star Trek Online Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Deletion vote[edit source]

A vote has been called to decided if this article will be deleted or kept.

To vote
Click [Edit] in the upper-right hand corner of the votes section, and add your vote in one the following methods:
  • {{vote|Keep|~~~~|optional comment}}
or
  • {{vote|Delete|~~~~|optional comment}}
Then click Save page and you are done!
Replace |~~~~| with |sig=~~~~|| if you have a complicated signature!
To discuss the vote
Click [Edit] in the upper-right hand corner of the comments section.

Votes[edit source]

Delete
  1. Delete Synonymously (talk) 11:49, 27 July 2013 (UTC) - (contains no information, with the author of this page even too lazy to remove the rest of the template (same with all pages listed [here]))
Keep
  1. Keep Tahno (talk) 03:13, 7 September 2013 (UTC) - (See comment below)
  2. Keep jveazey (talk) November 22, 2013 - (I am working on expanding doff mission givers and vendors)

Comments[edit source]


I'm not going to comment on each and every page linked under "what Links" to that header image, I'll just comment here, on the first one. This comment, and my "Keep" vote applies to all.

Just because the page has no information does not mean it is worthy of deletion. We call those "Stubs" and the pages that I saw have been marked as such. Rather than flag them for deletion the vote caller should attempt to add more information, or leave them for someone who can. These pages all describe NPC contacts in the game who give duty officer assignments, and they should, at some point, be documented as they are important NPCs that the player can interact with.

My only suggestion would be the naming. STO can be inconsistent with NPC names. Distinguishing factional names by adding (FED) or (KDF) works for a while, but then you find another "Tactical Officer" somewhere else and end up with more than one "Tactical Officer (FED)" etc. I would suggest moving (renaming) some of these pages based on location. Ie: "Tactical Officer (Ready Room)" or (Fed Bridge) or something, similar to how the generic Tailors have been done. Some thought needs to go into this, because in this example, The "Tactical Officer" is actually a shared console contacting several officers, on some bridges.

--Tahno (talk) 03:30, 7 September 2013 (UTC)

I've just noticed that the {{NPCinfo}} template caters for "Player Starship" as a location. This may be better than "Ready Room", as per my suggestion above.

--Tahno (talk) 05:41, 9 September 2013 (UTC)